TLDR: Overall I rate Manus 6/10 mostly because the website builder is really good. But if my agent was a person, they'd be fired and sent back to summer school!
I'm not a programmer. I wanted to use manus for getting stuff done, rather than generating sloppy copy from the declining ChatGpt.
Booking flights and adding them to my calendar sounded like an awesome use case.... until...
Imagine taking 1.5 hours to supervise your AI agent in doing 15 minutes worth of menial labor (in this case, booking a flight, a train, and putting the relevant into a calendar.
In the end Manus took so long I just did it myself. So let's call it a net negative for now. Maybe I'm the problem and I need to learn how to understand this delicate tech. But for now it's underwhelming.
I like using the voice to text, which is not as good as chatgpt but much better than Claude. However, on mobile and desktop, I'll give a long voice prompt, and the last couple seconds are completely missing.
I want the AI to work for me, but right now I'm working for the AI. Rocky start.
I will say that the website builder is impressive. What it did a good enough job of on first try for website copy, took chatgpt 5+ hours to tie into a gordian knot of word salad slop. And since I can host websites, Manus just became my new website hosting solution.
Sad that you can't really export your website to be usable on a third party host. Sad that the google calendar and gmail integrations seem to have severe reliablity issues.
Not sure if this is Google thwarting the competition or what, but so far google doesn't play well with ChatGpt or Manus, despite offering connectors.
My overall rating: 6/10. May go up as I discover more of Manus's strengths. But I can't unsee the epic time drain when it came to making calendar entries with gmail info. I expect an agentic tool to outperform a chat tool.
Epilogue: Manus and Chatgpt Agent where somehow unable to take travel booking information form my gmail and use it to make a google calendar event. And guess what? Claude chat did it first try in under a minute!
[link] [comments]